The unexplained disappearance and tragic death of Henry McCabe remain one of the most baffling unsolved cases in recent history. His case is particularly chilling due to a disturbing voicemail left on his wife’s phone, featuring agonizing screams, growls, and an unknown voice saying, “Stop it.”
Despite extensive investigations, law enforcement was unable to determine what truly happened to McCabe that fateful night. This article delves into his disappearance, the eerie voicemail, and the lingering questions surrounding his case.
Who Was Henry McCabe?
Henry McCabe was a 32-year-old Liberian immigrant who worked as an auditor for the Minnesota Department of Revenue. He was known as a hardworking professional, a dedicated family man, and someone who had no known enemies. His sudden disappearance on September 7, 2015, and the strange circumstances surrounding his death have led to multiple theories, ranging from accidental drowning to foul play and even paranormal involvement.
Timeline of Events: The Night Henry McCabe Disappeared
1. A Night Out Turns Mysterious
On the evening of September 6, 2015, Henry McCabe went to Povlitzki’s on 65, a nightclub in Spring Lake Park, Minnesota, with his friend William “Papaus” Kennedy. The two drank together, and according to Kennedy, McCabe was highly intoxicated when he drove him home.
Kennedy claimed he dropped McCabe off at a gas station in Fridley, Minnesota, around 2 a.m. However, digital records from McCabe’s phone and later investigations suggest he may have been dropped off elsewhere. This discrepancy raised suspicions but never led to any formal charges.
2. The Disturbing Voicemail (2:23 a.m.)
Shortly after 2 a.m., McCabe made a chilling call to his wife, Kareen McCabe, who was in California at the time. The voicemail lasted about two minutes and contained:
- Horrific screams and growls, as if McCabe was in immense pain.
- A series of moaning and gurgling sounds, possibly indicating distress or drowning.
- A deep, unknown voice at the end saying, “Stop it.”
The voicemail was sent to the FBI for analysis, but no conclusive findings were released regarding its origin or meaning. To this day, it remains one of the most disturbing aspects of the case.
3. Discovery of McCabe’s Body (November 2, 2015)
After nearly two months of searching, a kayaker found McCabe’s body floating in Rush Lake, New Brighton, Minnesota—six miles from where he was supposedly dropped off.
The autopsy ruled the cause of death as drowning, but several oddities raised further questions:
- No signs of physical trauma or struggle were found on his body.
- No wallet, keys, or phone were recovered, even though he had them earlier that night.
- How he ended up in the lake remained a mystery, especially since he was last seen miles away.
Key Mysteries and Unanswered Questions
1. The Voicemail: What Really Happened?
McCabe’s voicemail is one of the most eerie and unsettling recordings ever linked to a missing persons case. Experts and investigators have debated its possible explanations:
- Animal Attack? Some believe the growls and noises could be from an animal encounter, but there were no bite marks on his body.
- Torture or Assault? The screams suggest intense pain, leading some to suspect he was being attacked or tortured.
- Supernatural Elements? Given the strange sounds, some have speculated about paranormal interference.
To date, the exact source of the noises in the voicemail remains unknown.
2. Kennedy’s Contradictory Statements
McCabe’s friend William Kennedy initially claimed he dropped him off at a gas station. However, investigators found inconsistencies:
- No surveillance footage confirmed McCabe’s presence at the gas station.
- Phone tracking data suggested he may have been dropped off elsewhere.
- Kennedy was never charged, but his contradictory statements raised suspicions.
3. How Did McCabe End Up in Rush Lake?
- Rush Lake is six miles from Fridley, where Kennedy claimed to have left him.
- There is no evidence he walked there alone, as no witnesses reported seeing him.
- He was found with no personal belongings, further deepening the mystery.
Could he have been lured there, or did something supernatural play a role?
Theories About Henry McCabe’s Death
1. Accidental Drowning
- McCabe was heavily intoxicated, which might have caused disorientation.
- He could have wandered toward the lake and fallen in accidentally.
- However, this does not explain the disturbing voicemail or how he got to Rush Lake.
2. Foul Play
- The eerie voicemail suggests he was in distress, possibly being attacked.
- The voice saying “Stop it” hints that someone else was present.
- His missing belongings could indicate a robbery or cover-up.
3. Supernatural or Paranormal Involvement
- The unusual sounds in the voicemail have led some to believe he encountered something supernatural.
- Some theorists suggest he could have been possessed or attacked by an unknown entity.
- While speculative, this theory remains popular due to the voicemail’s unexplainable nature.
Also Read: Astaroth – The Mysterious Duke of Hell in Demonology!
Impact on the Investigation and Public Interest
The discovery of McCabe’s body in Rush Lake did not bring closure, but rather more questions. The investigation remained open for some time, but no further leads emerged.
His case continues to fascinate true crime enthusiasts, paranormal researchers, and conspiracy theorists due to its bizarre details. The voicemail alone has been analyzed repeatedly, yet no definite conclusions have been reached.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What was in the disturbing voicemail left by Henry McCabe?
The voicemail contained horrific screams, growls, and moans, followed by a deep voice saying “Stop it.” Experts have not been able to explain its origin.
2. How did the police respond to the voicemail recording from Henry McCabe?
The voicemail was analyzed by the FBI, but no conclusive findings were made public. Police considered it part of the mystery but did not determine its exact significance.
3. What were the findings of the search and rescue efforts for Henry McCabe?
After nearly two months, his body was found in Rush Lake. The official cause of death was drowning, but many details remain unexplained.
4. How did the discovery of Henry McCabe’s body impact the investigation?
The case remained open for some time, but without evidence of foul play, no charges were filed. His death was ruled accidental, despite lingering doubts.
5. What role did Kareen McCabe play in the investigation of Henry’s disappearance?
Kareen, Henry’s wife, was in California at the time of his disappearance. She received the disturbing voicemail and cooperated fully with authorities.
Conclusion: A Case That Still Haunts Investigators
The death of Henry McCabe remains one of the most disturbing unsolved cases in modern history. Whether it was an accident, foul play, or something beyond our understanding, the mystery endures. Until more evidence comes to light, the eerie voicemail, conflicting witness statements, and strange circumstances surrounding his death will continue to fuel speculation and intrigue. What do you think happened to Henry McCabe? Could it have been an accident, or is there something more sinister at play?
